Plan quality

Target Coverage

How much of the target receives the prescription dose — reported either as the share of the PTV receiving it or as the dose received by a set share of the PTV.

What is it?

Target coverage describes how completely the prescription dose covers the target. It is read from the target's dose-volume histogram in one of two directions:

  • Volume receiving a dose (Vx) — for example, the percentage of the PTV receiving at least the prescription dose. The NRG brain SRS template defines coverage this way: the PTV volume receiving the prescription dose divided by the PTV volume.
  • Dose received by a volume — for example, D95%, the dose that 95% of the PTV receives or exceeds. NRG's lung protocol templates define the nominal prescription as the dose covering 95% of the PTV, and add a protocol-specific D99% requirement.

Coverage is also described by near-minimum doses. ICRU Report 83 uses D98% as the low end of the target dose in its homogeneity index, and the RTOG radiosurgery guidelines defined a "quality of coverage" as the minimum target dose divided by the prescription.

Why does it matter?

Coverage is what the prescription promises: the target receiving the dose the physician intended. A plan can look excellent for every organ at risk simply because part of the target has been left cold.

Coverage is not the whole story either. Full coverage is easy if the prescription isodose is allowed to spill well beyond the target, which is why coverage is read together with conformity. The Paddick conformity index builds both into one number.

When coverage and an organ limit conflict, a protocol may set out which wins. The NRG lung SBRT template ranks its planning priorities: first respect the limits for the spinal canal, esophagus, brachial plexus, trachea, bronchus and stomach; then achieve PTV coverage; and where the PTV overlaps the organs in the next tier, allow coverage down to the protocol's "variation acceptable" level and minimize hotspots in the overlap.

How is it evaluated?

  1. Display the PTV's dose-volume histogram.
  2. Read the metric the protocol specifies — for example D95%, D99% or the percentage of the PTV receiving the prescription dose.
  3. Look at the plan slice by slice to see where any under-covered region sits — at the edge next to an organ at risk, or in the middle of the target.
  4. Where a GTV, ITV or CTV sits inside the PTV, check its coverage as well.

How a plan is normalized changes every coverage number, so record the normalization alongside them. The metrics and levels required are protocol-specific. DoseLab does not reproduce them; use the original protocol.

Example

Coverage = VPTV, Rx ÷ VPTV  (also read as V100% of the PTV)
D95% = dose received by 95% of the PTV
100%0VolumeDose →Rx95% of the PTVV100% = 95%D95% = RxPTV
Schematic PTV DVH. One point read two ways: 95% of the PTV receives the prescription dose, so the dose to 95% of the PTV equals the prescription.

Authoritative resources

Clinical resourceSource Verified
NRG Oncology Protocol Development Template for Radiation Therapy — Lung: Standard Fractionation
Matuszak M, Ritter T, Li Z, et al. · NRG Oncology Medical Physics Subcommittee / Radiation Oncology Committee · 2024

The NRG Oncology template for the radiation section of a conventionally fractionated lung trial. Its imaging section allows PET/CT or MRI for structure definition but asks that the final contours be confirmed on the planning CT, follows AAPM TG-132 for deformable registration, and notes that PET can help separate tumor from atelectasis. For plan evaluation it defines the prescription as the dose covering 95% of the PTV, with a protocol-specific D99% requirement, and asks that any dose above 105% of the prescription fall within the PTV rather than in normal tissue outside it.

Clinical resourceSource Verified
NRG Oncology Protocol Development Template for Radiation Therapy — Lung: SBRT
Matuszak M, Chetty I, Robinson C, Weldon M, Timmerman R · NRG Oncology Medical Physics Subcommittee / Radiation Oncology Committee · 2016

The template NRG Oncology gives investigators for writing the radiation section of a lung SBRT trial. Its imaging section allows PET/CT or MRI for structure definition, asks that the images be registered accurately to the planning scan (following AAPM TG-132 for deformable registration), notes that PET may be needed to separate tumor from atelectasis or fibrosis, and suggests an extra margin when a fused image is the primary image for the GTV. Its target and planning sections (5.2.4 and 5.2.6–5.2.8) define the plan-quality measures for lung SBRT trials: the prescription as the dose covering 95% of the PTV, a D99% requirement, R100% (prescription isodose volume ÷ PTV), R50% (50% prescription isodose volume ÷ PTV) and D2cm (maximum dose at 2 cm from the PTV in any direction, as a percentage of the prescription), with a table of allowable dose spillage by PTV volume. It describes a 20 mm PTV expansion structure used to control intermediate dose spillage, asks that dose above 105% of prescription be avoided outside the PTV, describes a deliberately heterogeneous dose with the hotspot in the central GTV, defines the maximum dose on a 0.03 cc volume, and ranks planning priorities when target coverage and organ limits conflict.

Clinical resourceSource Verified
NRG Oncology Protocol Development Template for Radiation Therapy — Brain: SRS
Cui Y, Ogunleye T, Kirkpatrick J, Xiao Y, Sperduto P, et al. · NRG Oncology Medical Physics Subcommittee / Radiation Oncology Committee · 2016

The NRG Oncology template for the radiation section of a brain radiosurgery trial. Its example text asks for CT slices of 1.25 mm or less, strongly encourages MRI (contrast T1 and a 3D gradient-echo sequence) for target delineation, recommends fusing FDG-PET/CT when available, and asks that the fusion be done by a medical physicist and reviewed by the attending physician. Its plan-evaluation section defines the conformity index (CI, or R100%) as the prescription isodose volume ÷ PTV volume, R50% as the 50% prescription isodose volume ÷ target volume ("R50% defines dose falloff outside the target"), a heterogeneity index D5% ÷ D95%, and coverage as the PTV volume receiving the prescription dose ÷ PTV volume, and notes that criteria such as the CI should account for target size and treatment technology.

Professional guidelineUnder Review
ICRU Report 83: Prescribing, Recording, and Reporting Photon-Beam Intensity-Modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT)
DeLuca P, Jones D, Gahbauer R, et al. · International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (ICRU) · 2010

ICRU report on prescribing, recording and reporting intensity-modulated photon therapy. DoseLab has not read the report itself (it is sold by the ICRU). Its homogeneity index, (D2% − D98%) / D50%, is checked as quoted in the open-access Yan 2019 paper.

Professional guidelineUnder Review
Radiation Therapy Oncology Group: radiosurgery quality assurance guidelines
Shaw E, Kline R, Gillin M, et al. · Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) · 1993

RTOG task-force guidelines for radiosurgery quality assurance, setting out a standard data set and minor and major protocol deviations. The paper itself is paywalled; DoseLab checked its conformity, coverage and homogeneity definitions as quoted in Kataria 2012 and Menon 2018. Citation checked against Crossref.

Planning studySource Verified

Retrospective evaluation of SRS/SRT plan-quality metrics for arteriovenous malformations. Its methods section defines each metric: the RTOG conformity index (prescription isodose volume ÷ target volume; ideal 1), RTOG quality of coverage and homogeneity index, and the Paddick conformity index as the product of the under-treatment ratio (share of the target covered) and over-treatment ratio (share of the prescription isodose volume inside the target), noting that ICRU Report 91 recommends the Paddick conformity and gradient indices for reporting stereotactic plans. Full text read in Europe PMC (PMC6299748); citation checked against Crossref.

TPS guidance

Eclipse

Step-by-step guidance planned. Added only once verified.

Coming soon
RayStation

Step-by-step guidance planned. Added only once verified.

Coming soon